When Travis Fox returns from war, the trauma of combat still haunts him, especially the death of his Christian friend. Nonetheless, Travis has sworn off Christianity altogether, wanting to move on with his life. However, the past won’t leave him alone, and new complications with Travis’ family don’t help matters. Will he ever be able to find peace?
Production Quality (2 points)
In keeping with most Christian productions that have come out since 2018, My Brother’s Keeper is mostly professional. Video quality, camera work, and audio are all in line with industry standards. For the most part, sets, locations, and props are acceptable although they sometimes don’t adequately represent what they’re supposed to portray. The biggest concern in this section is the choppy editing as some scenes cut and transition in awkward ways. Thus, this portion of the film receive a slightly above-average score.
Plot and Storyline Quality (0 points)
Throughout this narrative, the conversations and scenes come off as overly staged and unnatural, such as the forceful dialogue and messaging (including overt sermonizing) that leaves nothing to chance. These problems are only complicated by the many subplots that are juggled, which causes the story to lack focus. As a result, every character is a one-dimensional representation of an issue rather than an actual person. Despite potentially good PTSD flashbacks, these experiences are a bit overwrought instead of providing opportunities for the audience to connect with the character. Elsewhere, events in the narrative happen just because the writers want them to, and this extreme level of convenience causes the plot of aimlessly meander through a sea of empty platitudes and disorganized ideas. It goes without saying that there are also some very questionable portrayals of dual relationships and counseling ethics. In the end, there’s unfortunately no potential in this story, leading to zero points.
Acting Quality (1 point)
Despite acceptable line delivery, the emotions in this movie’s performances are very over-the-top. This is evidenced by lots of yelling and screaming, and it’s generally hard to believe that the cast members care about what they’re doing. Many of their performances are robotic and practiced although there are some bright spots. In the end, due to the errors, only a small score is warranted here.
My Brother’s Keeper is essentially another Christian issue screenplay, this time focusing on PTSD. Normally, this would be a good idea, but adequate research and firsthand accounts are needed to keep mental health portrayals realistic. There are many complex factors to consider, so crowding out this concept with subpar content isn’t the way to go. Unfortunately, this film is unable to connect with the audience, which likely means that it will be forgotten in a few weeks.
Final Rating: 3 out of 10 points