See original review here.
In keeping with most Worldwide Pictures films, Road to Redemption has a high-quality production, especially for the time period it was made in. There are no issues to point out here except for the use of cheesy special effects that try to accompany the eccentric genre of the film. However, if these small issues had been eliminated, then Road to Redemption would have had a perfect production.
Plot and Storyline Improvements
Road to Redemption is clearly a comedy, and it’s a pretty good one at that. It’s also quite a departure for a typical Worldwide Pictures film, which is great. However, sometimes the comedy is a bit cheesy, unless it is read in the context of satire, which is unfortunately unclear. Some parts seem to be included just to be eccentric, and thus the satire is not clear enough. For example, what’s up with the mafia subplot? It’s funny, but is this supposed to be serious or not? Also, character development is a bit lacking in some areas, and this is a needed element in any comedy. We need some more back story from the main characters beyond their representing of typical family issues. Finally, the ending too easily resolves the conflicts in unrealistic ways. Thus, had comedy been more rooted in reality, had the satire been clearer, had the characters been developed better through personality-building dialogue, and had the ending been less unrealistically patched up, then Road to Redemption could have been a Hall of Fame film.
Much like the commitment to high-quality productions, Worldwide Pictures also always demonstrated a commitment to high-quality casts. They were one of the few independent Christian film groups who seemed to employ acting coaching. However, there were some opportunities for improvement in Road to Redemption, such as Jay Underwood in general, who plays Alan. His delivery and emotions are annoying and whiny. If his character was written like that, then it needed to be changed. Also, the mafia cast members are a bit cheesy at times.
In the end, there were just a few minor issues that held Road to Redemption back from being all that it could be. With minor production errors eliminated, with a clearer comedy premise more based in reality, with a more effective use of satire, with deeper characters, and with a slightly better cast, Road to Redemption could have found itself on the Hall of Fame. However, perhaps someone can use the feedback here to make a better version one day.